Antiaromaticity
4n π electrons in a planar ring
An antiaromatic compound is a cyclic, planar, fully conjugated molecule with 4n π electrons (4, 8, 12, ...). Instead of being stabilized like benzene, it is destabilized, so such molecules are rare and highly reactive or distort to avoid the arrangement.
Show
Appearance
Resonance
Cyclooctatetraene: nonaromatic tub. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.
The real species is a resonance hybrid; contributors are bookkeeping views.
PubChem 3D conformer (CID 637866), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.
Key points
- Antiaromatic rings meet every aromatic criterion except the electron count.
- They are less stable than a comparable open-chain system.
- Many 4n rings avoid antiaromaticity by bending.
- Adding or removing electrons can switch between antiaromatic and aromatic.
Aromatic, antiaromatic, nonaromatic
Rings that are cyclic, planar and fully conjugated fall into two classes: 4n + 2 π electrons gives aromatic stabilization, and 4n π electrons gives antiaromatic destabilization.
A ring that is not planar or not fully conjugated is nonaromatic. It behaves like an ordinary alkene or alkane, with neither special stabilization nor destabilization.
Cyclobutadiene
Cyclobutadiene, C₄H₄, has 4 π electrons. It is so reactive that it dimerizes above very low temperatures and can be studied only in frozen inert matrices or as a metal complex.
Instead of a square with equal bonds, it adopts a rectangular structure with distinct single and double bonds, reducing the antiaromatic interaction.
The molecular orbital reason
For a square cyclobutadiene, Hückel theory gives one bonding π orbital and two degenerate nonbonding orbitals. Four π electrons fill the bonding orbital and leave one electron in each nonbonding orbital.
That half-filled, high-energy arrangement is unfavorable. Distortion to a rectangle splits the degenerate pair and lowers the energy.
Cyclooctatetraene escapes
Cyclooctatetraene (COT), C₈H₈, has 8 π electrons and would be antiaromatic if planar. It adopts a tub shape, so adjacent double bonds are twisted and it behaves as a nonaromatic polyene.
Adding two electrons gives the dianion C₈H₈²⁻, with 10 π electrons, which is planar and aromatic. Its C–C bond lengths alternate between about 133 and 146 pm, typical of separate double and single bonds rather than a delocalized ring.
Charged examples
The cyclopentadienyl cation (4 π electrons) and the cyclopropenyl anion (4 π electrons) are antiaromatic and very difficult to form.
The opposite ions, cyclopentadienide (6 π) and cyclopropenyl cation (2 π), are aromatic. The same ring can be aromatic or antiaromatic depending on its charge.
Using the concept
Antiaromaticity is clearest for small monocyclic rings. In larger or fused systems, the effects are weaker and harder to separate from strain and other factors.
Check planarity before applying the 4n label: a 4n ring that is not planar is nonaromatic.
Common questions
Is cyclooctatetraene antiaromatic?
No. It is tub-shaped and nonaromatic, although a planar form would be antiaromatic.
Is cyclobutadiene antiaromatic?
Yes. It is cyclic, conjugated and has 4 π electrons, making it highly unstable.
What is the difference between nonaromatic and antiaromatic?
Antiaromatic rings meet all aromatic criteria except having 4n electrons and are destabilized; nonaromatic rings fail the planarity or conjugation criteria.
Is the cyclopentadienyl cation antiaromatic?
Yes. C₅H₅⁺ is cyclic and conjugated with 4 π electrons, so in a planar form it is antiaromatic. It is extremely difficult to generate, unlike the aromatic cyclopentadienide anion.