MoleculeSensei
EN

Octet rule and exceptions

Eight valence electrons, and when not

The octet rule says that main-group atoms tend to form bonds until they are surrounded by eight valence electrons. It works well for carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, but there are three important exceptions: incomplete octets, odd-electron species and expanded octets.

Updated 3–5 min readFree 3D model, no sign-upSources

Show

Appearance

MoleculeSensei

SF₆: 12 electrons on S. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.

Idealised model: VSEPR angles and bond lengths estimated from covalent radii.

Key points

  • The octet rule is a guideline for main-group atoms.
  • Boron and beryllium often have fewer than eight electrons.
  • Molecules with an odd number of electrons cannot give every atom an octet.
  • Expanded octets occur only for period 3 and heavier atoms.

The octet rule

Atoms of the second period have one s and three p valence orbitals, which hold eight electrons. In most stable compounds of C, N, O and F, each atom is surrounded by four electron pairs.

Hydrogen follows a duet rule because its valence shell, 1s, holds only two electrons.

Incomplete octets

Boron in BF₃ has only six valence electrons. A structure with a B=F double bond would give boron an octet but places positive formal charge on fluorine, and measurements suggest only modest π donation.

Electron-deficient molecules are often Lewis acids. BF₃ readily accepts a lone pair from ammonia to complete boron’s octet. Gaseous BeCl₂ monomer has just four electrons on beryllium.

Odd-electron molecules

Nitric oxide has 11 valence electrons and nitrogen dioxide has 17. With an odd total, at least one atom must have an unpaired electron, so not every atom can have an octet.

These species are radicals. NO₂ readily pairs up to form N₂O₄, in which the odd electrons combine into an N–N bond.

Expanded octets

Elements in period 3 and below, such as P, S, Cl and Xe, form compounds with more than four bonds or lone pairs around the central atom. PCl₅ has 10 electrons around phosphorus; SF₆ and XeF₄ have 12.

These atoms are larger, so more atoms fit around them. Nitrogen forms NF₃ but not NF₅, because second-period atoms cannot exceed eight electrons.

What about d orbitals?

Older textbooks explain expanded octets by sp³d and sp³d² hybridization. Calculations show that d orbitals contribute little to bonding in these molecules.

Modern descriptions use delocalized bonding, such as three-center, four-electron bonds, with significant ionic character. Hypervalent is the common term for these molecules.

Using the rule sensibly

Start by trying to satisfy octets, then check formal charges and the electron total. If the count is odd or the central atom is from period 3 or below, an exception may apply.

Transition-metal compounds follow different counting rules, such as the 18-electron rule for many organometallic complexes.

Common questions

Why can sulfur have more than eight electrons but oxygen cannot?

Sulfur is a larger period 3 atom that can bond to more neighbors; second-period atoms like oxygen are limited to eight valence electrons.

Does BF₃ obey the octet rule?

No. In its usual Lewis structure boron has six valence electrons.

Why does NO break the octet rule?

It has an odd number of valence electrons (11), so one electron must be unpaired.

Does PCl₅ break the octet rule?

In its usual Lewis structure, phosphorus has five bonding pairs, or 10 electrons, so it is described as having an expanded octet. Modern bonding models explain it without needing d orbitals, but the electron count around phosphorus is still more than eight.