SN1 vs SN2
Unimolecular vs bimolecular substitution
SN2 is a one-step substitution in which the nucleophile attacks as the leaving group departs, giving inversion of configuration. SN1 is a two-step substitution through a carbocation, favored by tertiary substrates, weak nucleophiles and polar protic solvents.
Show
Appearance
Resonance
Bromomethane: SN2. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.
The real species is a resonance hybrid; contributors are bookkeeping views.
PubChem 3D conformer (CID 6323), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.
Key points
- SN2 is concerted; SN1 has a carbocation intermediate.
- Steric hindrance blocks SN2; carbocation stability enables SN1.
- Strong nucleophiles and polar aprotic solvents favor SN2.
- Secondary substrates can react by either path, depending on conditions.
Two mechanisms
In SN2 (substitution, nucleophilic, bimolecular), the nucleophile attacks carbon from the side opposite the leaving group. Bond making and bond breaking happen together in a single step through a five-coordinate transition state.
In SN1 (unimolecular), the leaving group departs first to form a planar carbocation. The nucleophile then bonds to that cation in a fast second step.
Rate laws
Because both the substrate and the nucleophile are in the SN2 transition state, the rate is k[RX][Nu]. Doubling the nucleophile concentration doubles the rate.
In SN1 only the substrate is involved in the slow ionization step, so the rate is k[RX]. Changing the nucleophile concentration does not change the rate.
Substrate structure
SN2 is fastest for methyl and primary substrates and very slow for tertiary ones, because bulky groups block backside attack. Bromomethane reacts readily; tert-butyl chloride essentially does not react by SN2.
SN1 depends on carbocation stability, so it favors tertiary, allylic and benzylic substrates. Methyl and primary substrates almost never react by SN1.
Stereochemistry
Backside attack makes SN2 stereospecific: a stereocenter undergoes inversion of configuration, like an umbrella turning inside out.
The planar carbocation in SN1 can be attacked from either face, so a stereocenter is largely racemized. Experimentally, a slight excess of inversion is common, because the departing leaving group briefly shields one face.
Nucleophile and solvent
Strong, negatively charged nucleophiles such as I⁻, CN⁻ or HS⁻ favor SN2. Polar aprotic solvents such as DMSO, DMF or acetone help by leaving the nucleophile poorly solvated and reactive.
Weak, neutral nucleophiles such as water or alcohols, often acting as the solvent, favor SN1. Polar protic solvents stabilize the carbocation and the leaving group as they separate.
Secondary substrates and competing reactions
Secondary substrates such as 2-bromobutane can react by either pathway, so conditions decide. They are also prone to elimination when the nucleophile is a strong base.
SN1 reactions can give rearranged products through hydride or alkyl shifts. Real reactions are often mixtures, so these trends describe tendencies rather than rules.
Common questions
How do you tell SN1 from SN2?
Look at the substrate, nucleophile and solvent: tertiary substrates with weak nucleophiles in protic solvents suggest SN1; unhindered substrates with strong nucleophiles in aprotic solvents suggest SN2.
Why does SN2 cause inversion?
The nucleophile attacks from the side opposite the leaving group, so the other three groups flip over.
Do tertiary halides undergo SN2?
Essentially no. Steric hindrance blocks backside attack.
Why do polar aprotic solvents speed up SN2?
Polar aprotic solvents such as DMSO and DMF dissolve ionic nucleophiles but cannot hydrogen bond to anions. The nucleophile is left with a loose solvent shell and stays highly reactive, whereas a protic solvent surrounds it with hydrogen bonds and slows its attack.