MoleculeSensei
EN

Carbocation stability

3° > 2° > 1° > methyl

Carbocations are carbon cations with only six valence electrons around the positive carbon. They are stabilized by neighboring alkyl groups and by resonance, giving the order tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl, with allylic and benzylic cations especially stable.

Updated 3–5 min readFree 3D model, no sign-upSources

Show

Appearance

MoleculeSensei

tert-Butyl cation: tertiary. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.

Idealised model: VSEPR angles and bond lengths estimated from covalent radii.

Key points

  • A carbocation is electron-deficient, with an empty p orbital.
  • Alkyl groups donate electron density by hyperconjugation.
  • Resonance delocalization can outweigh substitution.
  • More stable carbocations form faster and can drive rearrangements.

Structure of a carbocation

The positive carbon has three bonds and no lone pair, so it is sp² hybridized and trigonal planar. The remaining 2p orbital is empty and lies perpendicular to the plane.

With only six valence electrons, the carbon is strongly electron-poor. Anything that donates electron density toward it lowers its energy.

Hyperconjugation

A C–H or C–C σ bond on an adjacent carbon can overlap with the empty p orbital and share some of its electron density. This delocalization is called hyperconjugation.

The tert-butyl cation has nine C–H bonds positioned to donate this way; the methyl cation has none. Inductive donation from alkyl groups adds a smaller contribution in the same direction.

The stability order

Gas-phase measurements and solution rates both support tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl. This explains why tertiary halides react readily by SN1 and why HBr adds to alkenes with Markovnikov orientation.

Primary carbocations are so unstable that they are rarely genuine intermediates in solution; reactions of primary substrates usually take other pathways.

Resonance stabilization

When the positive carbon is next to a C=C double bond (allylic) or a benzene ring (benzylic), the charge is delocalized over several carbons. A primary benzylic cation can be about as stable as a secondary or tertiary alkyl cation.

The tropylium ion, C₇H₇⁺, is an extreme case: its six π electrons over seven carbons make it aromatic and stable enough to isolate as salts. Lone pairs on adjacent O or N also stabilize carbocations strongly.

Why it matters

Through the Hammond postulate, a more stable carbocation usually has a lower-energy transition state leading to it. Stability therefore controls rates of SN1 and E1 reactions and the regiochemistry of electrophilic additions.

Carbocations also rearrange: a hydride or alkyl group on a neighboring carbon can shift to convert a secondary cation into a more stable tertiary one.

Vinyl and aryl cations

A positive charge on a doubly bonded carbon (vinyl) or on a benzene ring carbon (aryl) is very unstable. The empty orbital there is sp-like or in the ring plane and cannot be stabilized well.

This is why aryl halides do not undergo SN1 under normal conditions.

Common questions

Why are tertiary carbocations more stable?

Three alkyl groups donate electron density through hyperconjugation and induction, spreading the positive charge.

Is a benzylic cation more stable than a tertiary one?

A tertiary benzylic cation is; a primary benzylic cation is roughly comparable to a secondary or tertiary alkyl cation, depending on the measure used.

What shape is a carbocation?

Trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital perpendicular to the plane.