Directing effects in aromatic substitution
Ortho, para and meta directors
A substituent already on a benzene ring controls where the next electrophile attacks. Electron-donating groups such as –OH, –NH₂ and alkyl groups direct to the ortho and para positions; electron-withdrawing groups such as –NO₂ and –C=O direct to meta.
Show
Appearance
Resonance
Toluene: ortho/para, activating. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.
The real species is a resonance hybrid; contributors are bookkeeping views.
PubChem 3D conformer (CID 1140), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.
Key points
- Activating groups speed up substitution; deactivating groups slow it.
- Most activators direct ortho/para; most deactivators direct meta.
- Halogens deactivate the ring but still direct ortho/para.
- The explanation is the stability of the arenium ion intermediate.
The intermediate decides
Electrophilic aromatic substitution goes through a positively charged arenium ion (σ complex). The step that forms it is slow, so whatever stabilizes this cation speeds up the reaction at that position.
For attack ortho or para to a substituent, one resonance form of the arenium ion places the positive charge on the ring carbon bearing the substituent. For meta attack, the charge never reaches that carbon.
Ortho/para directors
Groups with a lone pair on the attached atom, such as –OH, –OCH₃ and –NH₂, donate electrons by resonance. They stabilize the ortho and para arenium ions strongly, adding an extra resonance form in which every atom has an octet.
Alkyl groups donate weakly by induction and hyperconjugation. Nitration of toluene gives mainly ortho and para products, with only a few percent meta.
Meta directors
Groups such as –NO₂, –CN, –CHO, –COR and –SO₃H withdraw electron density and carry a positive or δ+ atom next to the ring. Ortho or para attack would place the arenium positive charge right next to that atom, which is especially unfavorable.
Meta attack avoids this, so it is the least disfavored path. These groups slow the reaction overall; nitrobenzene nitrates much more slowly than benzene.
The halogen exception
Halogens withdraw electrons inductively, which deactivates the ring. But their lone pairs can still donate by resonance into the ortho and para arenium ions.
The result is a deactivated ring that still reacts mainly at ortho and para positions. Chlorobenzene nitrates more slowly than benzene but gives mostly ortho and para products.
Ortho versus para
Statistically there are two ortho positions and one para, but bulky substituents or electrophiles block the ortho sites. tert-Butylbenzene gives mostly para product.
When two substituents are present, the stronger activator usually controls the outcome.
Conditions can change the director
Aniline is a strong ortho/para director, but in strongly acidic nitrating mixtures it is largely protonated to the anilinium ion, –NH₃⁺. That group is a meta director, so significant meta product forms.
Chemists often convert –NH₂ to an amide first to moderate its activation and protect it.
Common questions
Is a methyl group ortho/para or meta directing?
Ortho/para, and it mildly activates the ring.
Why is –NO₂ a meta director?
Ortho or para attack would put the arenium ion’s positive charge next to the positive nitrogen, so meta attack is favored.
Why are halogens ortho/para directors if they deactivate the ring?
Inductive withdrawal slows the reaction, but lone-pair donation still stabilizes the ortho and para intermediates.
Which product forms when anisole is brominated?
Mostly para-bromoanisole, with some ortho product. The methoxy group donates electrons by resonance and activates the ring so strongly that bromination can occur without a Lewis acid catalyst.