Electron vs molecular geometry
Domains vs atom positions
Electron geometry describes the arrangement of all electron domains around a central atom, including lone pairs. Molecular geometry describes only the positions of the atoms, so the two names differ whenever the central atom has lone pairs.
Show
Appearance
Resonance
Water: tetrahedral / bent. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.
The real species is a resonance hybrid; contributors are bookkeeping views.
Idealised model: VSEPR angles and bond lengths estimated from covalent radii.
Key points
- Count domains first to get the electron geometry.
- Remove lone pairs from the description to name the molecular shape.
- With no lone pairs on the center, the two geometries are the same.
- Experiments locate atoms, so molecular geometry is what is measured.
The key difference
Both descriptions start from the electron domains around a central atom: each bond (single, double or triple) and each lone pair counts once. The domains arrange themselves to minimize repulsion, giving the electron geometry.
The molecular geometry names the shape made by the atoms alone. Lone pairs influence that shape but are not part of its name.
Four domains: methane, ammonia and water
Methane, ammonia and water all have four electron domains, so all have a tetrahedral electron geometry.
Methane has four bonds and is tetrahedral. Ammonia has three bonds and one lone pair and is trigonal pyramidal. Water has two bonds and two lone pairs and is bent.
Five and six domains
With five domains the electron geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. Lone pairs occupy equatorial positions, giving seesaw SF₄ (one lone pair), T-shaped ClF₃ (two) and linear XeF₂ (three).
With six domains the electron geometry is octahedral. One lone pair gives square pyramidal BrF₅; two lone pairs, placed opposite each other, give square planar XeF₄.
A reliable procedure
Draw the Lewis structure and count bonding domains (X) and lone pairs (E) on the central atom. Use the total to name the electron geometry, then use the AXₘEₙ pattern to name the molecular geometry.
For example, AX₂E₂ is tetrahedral electron geometry and bent molecular geometry; AX₂E is trigonal planar electron geometry and bent molecular geometry, as in SO₂.
What each description is for
Molecular geometry is what diffraction and spectroscopy measure, because they locate nuclei. Electron geometry is a model-based description used to explain those shapes.
Both are idealized. Real angles deviate from the ideal values, and VSEPR does not reliably describe many transition-metal compounds.
Using the models
Switch between methane, ammonia and water to see how lone pairs change the shape name while the electron geometry stays tetrahedral. SF₄ shows a five-domain case with one equatorial lone pair.
Lone pairs are not drawn as atoms in the models. Their influence appears as the space left around the central atom and the compressed bond angles.
Common questions
Are electron and molecular geometry ever the same?
Yes, whenever the central atom has no lone pairs, as in CH₄, BF₃ and SF₆.
What is the electron geometry of water?
Tetrahedral, because oxygen has four electron domains: two bonds and two lone pairs.
Why are both water and SO₂ bent?
Both have bent molecular shapes, but water has four domains (AX₂E₂) and SO₂ has three (AX₂E), so their electron geometries differ.
What are the electron and molecular geometries of XeF₄?
Xenon has four bonding domains and two lone pairs, six domains in total, so the electron geometry is octahedral. The lone pairs sit opposite each other, leaving the four fluorines in a square: the molecular geometry is square planar.