MoleculeSensei
EN

Substitution vs elimination

SN1, SN2, E1 and E2

Alkyl halides can undergo substitution (a nucleophile replaces the leaving group) or elimination (a base removes a β-hydrogen to form an alkene). Which pathway wins depends mainly on the substrate, the strength and size of the base or nucleophile, the solvent and the temperature.

Updated 3–5 min readFree 3D model, no sign-upSources

Show

Appearance

MoleculeSensei

2-Bromobutane: secondary. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.

PubChem 3D conformer (CID 6554), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.

Key points

  • Substrate class is the first thing to check.
  • Strong, bulky bases favor elimination.
  • Good nucleophiles that are weak bases favor substitution.
  • Real reactions often give mixtures.

Two competing outcomes

In substitution, the nucleophile attacks the carbon bearing the leaving group. In elimination, a base removes a hydrogen from the neighboring (β) carbon, and a C=C bond forms as the leaving group departs.

Many reagents, such as hydroxide and ethoxide, are both nucleophiles and bases, so both pathways compete. The carbon bearing the leaving group is called the α-carbon, and the neighboring carbons are β-carbons. Elimination removes a hydrogen from a β-carbon.

Start with the substrate

Methyl and primary halides favor SN2 because backside attack is easy. Bromoethane with ethoxide gives mainly diethyl ether.

Tertiary halides cannot undergo SN2. With a strong base they give E2 alkenes; in a weakly basic, polar protic solvent they ionize and give SN1 and E1 products together.

Secondary halides

Secondary halides are the hardest to predict. With a strong base such as ethoxide, 2-bromobutane gives mostly elimination, forming but-2-ene as the major alkene.

With a good nucleophile that is a weak base, such as I⁻, CN⁻ or N₃⁻, in a polar aprotic solvent, SN2 dominates.

Strength and size of the base

Bulky strong bases such as potassium tert-butoxide find it hard to reach carbon but can easily remove an exposed hydrogen. They favor E2 and often give the less substituted (Hofmann) alkene.

Smaller strong bases usually give the more substituted (Zaitsev) alkene as the major product.

Solvent and temperature

Polar aprotic solvents favor SN2 by keeping anionic nucleophiles reactive. Polar protic solvents support carbocation formation for SN1 and E1.

Higher temperatures favor elimination, because elimination produces more molecules and is helped more by entropy. The TΔS term grows as temperature rises.

Using the guidelines

These trends summarize many experiments, but product ratios depend on the exact substrate and conditions. E2 also requires a β-hydrogen positioned anti-periplanar to the leaving group, which matters in rings.

Expect mixtures and check the literature or experiment for the actual ratio.

Common questions

Does a tertiary halide give substitution or elimination?

With a strong base, mainly E2 elimination; with a weak nucleophile in a protic solvent, a mixture of SN1 and E1.

Why does heat favor elimination?

Elimination increases the number of molecules, so its entropy change is more favorable, and the TΔS term grows with temperature.

Which base favors the less substituted alkene?

A bulky base such as tert-butoxide.

What is the difference between Zaitsev and Hofmann products?

The Zaitsev product is the more substituted, usually more stable alkene. The Hofmann product is the less substituted alkene, often favored by bulky bases that remove the most accessible hydrogen.