Curly arrows
Showing electron movement
Curly arrows show the movement of electrons in a reaction mechanism or between resonance structures. A full-headed arrow moves an electron pair; a half-headed fishhook arrow moves a single electron.
Show
Appearance
Resonance
Bromomethane: electrophile. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.
The real species is a resonance hybrid; contributors are bookkeeping views.
PubChem 3D conformer (CID 6323), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.
Key points
- Arrows always start at electrons, never at an atom’s nucleus or a positive charge.
- The arrowhead shows where the electrons end up.
- Fishhook arrows are for radical reactions.
- Curly arrows, reaction arrows and resonance arrows mean different things.
The basic rules
A curly arrow starts at a source of electrons: a lone pair, a π bond or a σ bond. It ends where those electrons go: on an atom (making a lone pair) or between two atoms (making a new bond).
A common mistake is drawing an arrow from H⁺ to a base. The arrow should start at the base’s lone pair and point to the H.
Worked example: SN2
When hydroxide reacts with bromomethane, one arrow starts at an oxygen lone pair and points to carbon, forming the new C–O bond. A second arrow starts at the C–Br bond and points to bromine, which leaves as Br⁻.
After the arrows are drawn, count charges: oxygen loses its negative charge and bromine gains one. The total charge stays −1.
Fishhook arrows for radicals
A half-headed arrow moves one electron. Homolysis of Cl₂ needs two fishhooks, one from the bond to each chlorine atom.
Using a full arrow for a radical step implies an electron pair moving and gives the wrong products. Each fishhook carries one electron, so forming a bond between two radicals also needs two fishhooks, one from each radical.
Arrows in resonance structures
Curly arrows also convert one resonance contributor into another. In carbonate, a lone pair on O⁻ moves to form C=O while the π electrons of another C=O move onto oxygen.
The double-headed resonance arrow (↔) between contributors is not a reaction arrow and not an equilibrium arrow (⇌). No atoms move, and nothing is converted.
Checking your arrows
After every step, check that second-period atoms have no more than eight valence electrons, that formal charges are correct, and that the overall charge is unchanged.
If an arrow would give carbon five bonds, another arrow is missing: a bond to that carbon must break at the same time.
What arrows do and do not show
Curly arrows are a bookkeeping notation that matches proposed mechanisms. They do not show the timing of electron motion or the exact path electrons take.
A mechanism drawn with correct arrows still needs experimental support, such as rate laws and stereochemistry, to be accepted.
Common questions
Where should a curly arrow start?
At a lone pair or a bond: the electrons that move.
What is the difference between a full arrow and a fishhook arrow?
A full arrowhead moves an electron pair; a fishhook moves one electron, used in radical mechanisms.
Do curly arrows show atoms moving?
No. They show electrons; atoms follow as a consequence of bond changes.
Can a curly arrow start from a positive charge?
No. A positive charge marks an electron-poor atom, so it can only be the destination of an arrow. Arrows always start at electrons: a lone pair, a π bond or a σ bond.