MoleculeSensei
EN

Markovnikov’s rule

Regioselectivity of HX addition

Markovnikov’s rule predicts the main product when HX adds to an unsymmetrical alkene: hydrogen attaches to the carbon that already has more hydrogens, and X attaches to the more substituted carbon. The modern reason is that the reaction goes through the more stable carbocation.

Updated 3–5 min readFree 3D model, no sign-upSources

Show

Appearance

MoleculeSensei

Propene. Drag to rotate; click the model, then scroll or use + and − to zoom; click an atom to identify it.

PubChem 3D conformer (CID 8252), a computed low-energy shape; flexible molecules adopt many conformations.

Key points

  • The rule describes regioselectivity, not whether a reaction happens.
  • Carbocation stability explains the rule: tertiary > secondary > primary.
  • Radical and hydroboration mechanisms give the opposite orientation.
  • Carbocations can rearrange, giving products the simple rule does not predict.

The rule in two forms

Markovnikov’s original observation: in the addition of HX to an alkene, H goes to the carbon with more hydrogen atoms and X to the carbon with fewer. Adding HBr to propene gives mainly 2-bromopropane, not 1-bromopropane.

The mechanistic form is more general: an electrophile adds to an alkene so that the more stable carbocation forms. This version also covers additions that do not involve HX.

Why it works: the carbocation step

The π bond of the alkene attacks H⁺ in the slow first step, creating a carbocation on one of the two former alkene carbons. Bromide then bonds to that positive carbon in a fast second step.

For propene, protonation at C1 gives a secondary carbocation, while protonation at C2 gives a primary one. The secondary cation is lower in energy, and by the Hammond postulate the transition state leading to it is also lower.

Carbocation stability order

Alkyl groups stabilize a positive carbon through hyperconjugation and inductive donation, so the order is tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl. Isobutylene adds HBr to give tert-butyl bromide via the tertiary cation.

Resonance can outweigh simple substitution. A benzylic or allylic cation is especially stable because the positive charge is delocalized.

Anti-Markovnikov additions

HBr in the presence of peroxides adds by a radical chain mechanism. A bromine atom adds first, forming the more stable carbon radical, so Br ends up on the less substituted carbon.

Hydroboration–oxidation also places OH on the less substituted carbon. These are not violations of the mechanistic principle; they simply involve different intermediates.

When the rule is not the whole story

Because a carbocation is involved, a hydride or alkyl shift can convert it into a more stable cation before the nucleophile adds. 3-Methylbut-1-ene with HCl gives a substantial amount of 2-chloro-2-methylbutane through such a shift.

Markovnikov selectivity is a strong preference, not an absolute rule. Product ratios depend on the substrate and conditions.

Hydration and other additions

The same principle applies to acid-catalysed hydration. Water adds to propene to give propan-2-ol, because protonation forms the secondary carbocation, which water then attacks.

Halohydrin formation follows the same pattern through a bromonium ion: the nucleophile, water, bonds to the more substituted carbon, which carries more of the positive charge.

Common questions

What is the simplest way to remember Markovnikov’s rule?

Hydrogen adds to the alkene carbon that already has more hydrogens.

Why does HBr with peroxides give the anti-Markovnikov product?

Peroxides start a radical chain in which a bromine atom adds first, forming the more stable carbon radical.

Does Markovnikov’s rule apply to symmetrical alkenes?

No. In ethene or but-2-ene both carbons are equivalent, so there is no regiochemical choice.

What product forms when HCl adds to 2-methylpropene?

Mainly 2-chloro-2-methylpropane (tert-butyl chloride). Protonation at the CH₂ end gives the tertiary tert-butyl cation, which chloride then traps. The alternative primary cation is far less stable, so 1-chloro-2-methylpropane forms only in trace amounts, if at all.